Wednesday, September 16, 2009

Leave me alone

010I just stumbled upon a blog of a woman that I kind of used to know. I saw her comment on a different blog and I got to wondering what she was up to. I was poking around and saw we had totally different political views. *shrug* Totally different religious views. *shrug* I went to a section entitled "Rantings of a Bad Mom." It was a tongue in cheek tribute to, uh, well....herself.

She openly mocked mothers that read parenting books, followed OB and pediatrician advice, ate carefully, gave up caffeine, whose kids had a bedtime, had medical interventions during labor, joined a playgroup, bought a Baby Einstein video, didn't co-sleep, choose not to give their kids sugar, pureed their baby's food, etc, etc. She pretty much held in contempt any woman who made a decision that she hadn't made with her kids. These mothers were called "uneducated bandwagon mentality people on internet message boards." She's charming, no?

Normally I could brush all this off, but it really got me tonight. How dare she? How dare she judge women that attempt to do their best? Women that pour over books (like me) to look for answers, theories and thoughts *gasp* outside of ourselves? This learning is somehow ridiculous. Women that turn to other mothers for support in the form of a playgroup are weak? Women that choose to eat healthy while pregnant are foolish? I'm just amazed.

There are many ways that you can discuss your beliefs and passions without ridiculing millions of hard working mothers. She somehow missed each and everyone of them. As did her brown-nosing minions in her comment section.

Maybe this bothered me so much because I have felt this harsh, undeserved judgment. I felt it when I chose to give my tiny son avocado at 4.5 months in a desperate attempt to get him to gain weight. I felt this judgment when I chose to leave my son just as perfect as he was born and not circumcise him. I feel this judgment now when my very exuberant and energy-packed almost two-year-old can't quite make it through dinner at a restaurant.

Alfie Kohn mentioned in Unconditional Parenting (awesome book for any of you idiots looking to better yourself or expand your thinking) that our society isn't friendly to kids, the whole "kids should be seen and not heard" mentality is really pervasive in our culture. I totally agree, but I think our culture is even harsher on moms.

Little dude is a vegetarian and I have been told that I am depriving him. (This is particularly confusing for people that first comment on how healthy/vigorous/or tall he is before finding out. Then they have no where to find fault because he's obviously thriving). I chose to not use bottles and sippies with BPA and I was told that I was being overprotective. I buy organic when I can and I am told that I am wasting my money. Starting at about 6 months people were asking when I was going to wean, you should have seen the looks I got when I said, "when we are done." We skipped the rice cereal and were told that we were doing things wrong. Oh, and the pacifier. Don't get me started on that pacifier. He is not 40, people. He is ONE.

Most of the time I feel like I walk around with a massive target on me that reads: "Hey, ask me about my parenting."

But I swear, I checked and there isn't one. I asked Trey too, and he can't see one either.

I just wish we had a culture where mothers and children were lifted up instead of being torn down continually (I feel like this as an educator too, but that's quite another story). Where I could look to my fellow mother and feel support and kinship and maybe even love. Love for this shared journey we are on and empathy for the difficult task we have all chosen to undertake.

7 had something to say:

Karly said...

Love that last paragraph, Jamie. Beautifully well said.

Ei said...

Hugs James. Something I've struggled with for 10 years...sometimes even when I'm dealing with the man with whom I chose to procreate (Like the new title?).

I think that a) it isn't a problem that is going away soon, it's pervasive and ugly and b) the bigger framework is about how women treat themselves and each other, regardless of their mom status, and how it fits into how society brands women. It's complicated and overwhelming.

I like to say that parenting is an art, not a science. None of us can get away with painting by the numbers, but learning a skill set is smart. She doesn't get that, but it's okay. Even apes get lucky by throwing some paint at a canvas sometimes.

Brenna said...

Hi, my name is Brenna. My sister (findingchaos.com) reads your blog and sent me a link. I live in Austin too!! She saw that you knit and well, I am knitting obsessed. I also have a son and he turns 3 in October.

I couldn't agree with you more on this post. Wonderfully written and so very true. I remember when I was pregnant, standing in front of the hot dogs at the grocery store. We were having a BBQ and I was stocking up. This woman came up to me and said "You know, you shouldn't be eating hot dogs. It can really hurt your baby." Too bad she didn't see the tofu dogs already in my basket. I was flabbergasted. The nerve of some stranger judging me like that. A couple of months ago I was in the store (HEB) and my son who is almost 3 now (he LOVES the movie CARS too!!!) was eating a cookie. The woman behind me in line asked how I felt about letting my son have food coloring in his cookie. Again, flabbergasted. It was then that I told her I did not mind one bit and that when we get home I am going to let him watch TV. haha

My philosophy has always been to do what works best for you and your family. If that means giving my son a pink cookie so I can get our weekly grocery shopping done, then so be it. btw - he calls HEB the "Cookie Store". haha

Oh and I prefer Central Market over HEB any day.

veganbaby said...

You are so profound, Jamie.

brenna said...

Hi, another brenna and another first time poster. Weird.

I just wanted to say "well said." The more women who speak out about this and refuse to accept the "judge or be judged" mentality, the better off our children and home-lives will be.

Jamie said...

Hi Brennas!

Em said...

I couldn't agree more Jamie. I wish I had something more intelligent than that to say, but that's all I've got tonight!

Post a Comment

Blog Widget by LinkWithin